Wood anatomy ontology meeting, 2012 at NYBG, agenda
Dates: 5-7 February, 2012 (Sunday through Tuesday)
Location: Lewis B. and Dorothy Cullman Conference Room, Pfizer Laboratory, New York Botanical Garden
This page has a Tiny Url: http://tinyurl.com/7dyv4f9
From the Plant Ontology Consortium:
- Dennis Stevenson, Vice President for Laboratory Research, New York Botanical Garden
- Ramona Walls, Post-doctoral researcher and Plant Ontology curator, New York Botanical Garden
- Maria Alejandra Gandolfo, Cornell University
- Laurel Cooper, PO Project Coordinator and Curator, Oregon State University
- Andrew Groover: Plant Biology, Geneticist, USDA Forest Service, Institute of Forest Genetics
- Jill Wegrzyn of the TreeGenes Database at UCDavis, Bioinformatics
- Frederic Lens Netherlands Centre for Biodiversity Naturalis, wood anatomy
- Barb Lachenbruch College of Forestry, Oregon State University, wood science and anatomy
- Elisabeth Wheeler North Carolina State University, paleobotany and wood anatomy; curator of the Inside Wood database -unable to attend due to a personal emergency
- Rachel Spicer Connecticut College, wood anatomy, development, and physiology
- Meg (Margeret) Staton Fagaceae Genomics Web, curator; bioinformatics
Lodging and Transportation
Guests will be staying at the Hamptom Inn and Suites, in Yonkers, NY, approximately 15 minutes from the NYBG. Transportation to and from the hotel will be provided by van service or private cars.
The PO will arrange a car service from the airport to the hotel using PondField Car Service. We do not recommend using taxis.
It will be cool, with highs is the low 40's.
Please bring a sweater or jacket, as the conference room can be quite cold.
1. Develop ontology terms and definitions for wood structure, as part of the Plant Anatomical Entity branch of the Plant Ontology.
2. Develop ontology terms and definitions the time course of development of wood, as part of the Plant Structure Development Stage branch of the Plant Ontology.
3. Develop ontology terms and definitions, as well as ontology structure, for wood qualities and phenotypes, as an extension of the Plant Ontology and other ontologies, such as the Trait Ontology (TO) and Phenotypic Quality Ontology (PATO, formerly the Phenotype and Trait Ontology).
By the end of the meeting, we will have list of terms for these three areas (anatomy, development stages, qualities), plus proposed definitions, and a good idea of how the terms will fit into the PO.
Agenda, Sunday, Feb. 5, 2011
9:00AM-12:00PM Introduction to Bio-ontologies - Public Session
This session will be open to people outside the meeting participants, and will be advertised to the wider scientific community.
If you are interested in attending this session, please contact Ramona Walls by February 1, 2012.
Link to the meeting announcment.
9AM-9:15AM Welcome and Introductions (Dennis Stevenson)
9:15AM-11:00AM Introduction to Bio-ontologies (Barry Smith)
Barry Smith, an ontology expert and consultant to the PO, will provide an introduction to ontologies for the life sciences.
Link to Barry's presentation: Media:Smith_BioOntology_Intro_Feb2012.pdf
See link to NCBO page
1. What is an ontology and what is it for?
2. Ontology success stories in the life sciences
3. The bio-ontologies landscape
- Open Biomedical Ontologies (OBO) Foundry
- National Center for Biomedical Ontology (NCBO) and its Bioportal
- Ontologies and the Semantic Web
4. How to build your first ontology
-with illustrations from the Plant Ontology
- definitions and cross-products
- types and instances
- use of OBO-Edit and Protege
11:00AM-11:15AM Coffee break
11:15AM-12:00PM Introduction to the Plant Ontology (Ramona Walls)
Link to Ramona's presentation: Media:PO_Walls_wood_meeting_short.pdf
1. What is the Plant Ontology and what is it for?
2. How the Plant Ontology is structured: anatomy and development stages
- The two main branches of the PO are plant anatomical entity and plant structure development stage
3. Plant Ontology relations and definitions
- Types and subtypes: is_a, the fundamental relation in the PO
- Parts: part_of and has_part; what they means for anatomical entities (things) versus development stages (processes); when to use has_part instead of part_of
- Development and derivation: the develops_from and derives_by_manipulation_from relations
- Specifying spatial relations: adjacent_to, part_of, and other relations
- Links between anatomical entities and development stages: the participates_in and has_participant relations
- Definitions for humans and computers
- Genus-differentia definitions - importance of reading up the tree for properties of a term
- Logical definitions and relations
4. Neighboring ontologies of the PO: Traits (TO) and Phenotypes (PATO)
- Domains of Trait Ontology (TO), and Phenotypic Quality Ontology (PATO), versus the PO
- How do they differ? How are they similar? How do they interact?
- The difference between an entity and a phenotype
- What is a trait? What is a quality?
5. Different types of plant data made available through the Plant Ontology
- Linking genomic and phenomic data to PO terms
- Example: mapping maize tissue samples to PO terms
- How annotation files are created and maintained; responsibilities of the PO versus contributing databases. (Will be covered by Laurel Cooper's presentation on Monday evening.)
Lunch at the Garden Cafe
1:00PM-2:00PM Overview of the goals for the meeting
Review of goals
The following goals were established prior to this meeting:
What are users' needs?
-In addition to working on the terms used to describe wood, we can review the needs for other anatomy terms for woody plants that may not be in the PO (e.g., reproductive structures in gymnosperms).
Achieving our goals
At the meeting, we will develop lists of new terms as well as revisions to existing terms that are needed for the PO, and begin work on definitions and relations for these terms.
At the end of the meeting, we will assess our progress, and create a list of tasks to be completed, plus a timeline.
All participants will set up an account to access our SourceForge tracker. This will allow us to continue to work on new terms and definitions after the workshop.
Feedback after this meeting
Interactive demo on how to:
- give feedback on PO web page.
- request new terms or revisions on PO's SourceForge tracker.
2:00PM-2:45PM Flash talks by participants
5 minutes per person. A computer and projector will be available if anyone wants to use them. Talks should be no more than 8 slides, but slides are not required.
Links to presentations:
- Maria Alejandra Gandolfo, Cornell University: Media:MAG_PO_Workshop.pdf
- Andrew Groover: Plant Biology, Geneticist, USDA Forest Service, Institute of Forest Genetics: Media:Groover_NYBG.pdf
2:45PM-3:00PM Coffee Break
3:00PM-6:30PM Work on goal 1 - Anatomical Entities
Goal 1. Develop ontology terms and definitions for wood structure, as part of the Plant Anatomical Entity branch of the Plant Ontology.
- review existing anatomy/morphology terms and definitions
- develop list of anatomy/morphology terms that are missing
- work on definitions of new terms
See separate page, Goal 1. Anatomical Entities, for more details and minutes from the meeting.
7:00PM-9:00PM Dinner at Wild Ginger
Wild Ginger is an Asian fusion restaurant in the village of Bronxville, about 15 minutes north of the NYBG.
Address: 10 Park Place, Bronxville, NY 10708, (914)337-2198
Transportation to the restaurant and back to the hotel will be provided.
Agenda, Monday, Feb. 6, 2011
9:00AM-12:00PM Work on goal 2 - Development stages
Goal 2. Develop ontology terms and definitions for the time course of development of wood, as part of the Plant Structure Development Stage branch of the Plant Ontology
- review existing development stage terms and definitions
- develop list of development stage terms that are missing
- work on definitions of new terms
See separate page, Goal 2. Plant Structure Development Stages, for more details and minutes from the meeting.
-If necessary, we can also make suggestions for developmental processes in the Gene Ontology.
There will be time for a coffee break in the middle of the morning.
NYBG is closed on Mondays. We will order in lunch from a Mike's Deli.
1:00PM-2:00PM Continue work on goal 2
3:00PM-6:00PM Work on goal 3 - Qualities and Phenotypes
Goal 3. Develop ontology terms and definitions, as well as ontology structure, for wood qualities and phenotypes.
- Wood qualitites and phenotypes will for an extension of the Plant Ontology and other ontologies, such as the Trait Ontology (TO) and Phenotypic Quality Ontology (PATO, formerly the Phenotype and Trait Ontology).
- Background on PO, TO, PATO
- How to describe qualities using ontologies
- Resources for terms
See separate page, Goal 3. Wood qualities and phenotypes, for more details and minutes from the meeting.
There will be time for a coffee break in the middle of the afternoon.
6:00-8:30 Working dinner and evening session at NYBG
We will order in dinner from an Italian restaurant located in the Bronx's Little Italy, the Arthur Avenue neighborhood.
- Laurel Cooper, PO Project Coordinator and Curator, Oregon State University: Media:Cooper_PO.pdf
Agenda, Tuesday, Feb. 7, 2011
8:30AM-9:30AM Review ontology structure from days 1 and 2
- Review of any unfinished items from goals 1-3.
- Set priorities for remaining tasks.
9:30AM-10:40AM Break-out groups
1. Compile list of wood traits for which genomic data are currently being collected (Laurel, Meg, Jill, Andrew).
2. Complete definitions for secondary xylem development stages. Work on terms for sub-cellular anatomical entities needed to describe wood. (Ramona, Frederic, Barb, Dennis, Rachel)
10:40AM-11:20PM Wrap up
- What still needs to be done?
- Who will do what?
- Timeline for meeting our goals
Plant anatomical entities and development stages
- RW (with DWS and MAG) will prepare list of anatomical terms, plus definitions, for PO and GO, and send to group for review.
(See Goal_1._Anatomical_Entities for more details)
- Secondary xylem development stage terms are nearly complete (see Goal_2._Plant_Structure_Development_Stages#wood_development_stages ). These will go in the PO now, along with general terms for secondary phloem development stage, and bark development stage, which can be fleshed out as needed.
- Need to talk to GO about their term for "lignin network" -- is it in or out of cell, should it be in PO or GO?
- Need to talk to POC about whether/how to include specialized terms like storied cambium, vascular bundle types.
- RW will be responsible for getting anatomy and development terms into PO and GO by September, 2012.
See Goal_3._Wood_qualities_and_phenotypes for more details
- Wood traits for which genomic data are currently being collected -- add these to the TO by September 2012 (LC)
- Work with GO and ChEBI to get terms needed for wood traits (LC, others?)
- What about concerns over TO general structure?
LC will work with MS and JW to integrate the PO with their Wood databases and develop association data sets for the PO. Some of this can be done in the short term, as the Hardwood Genomics group has been using PO terms to annotate gene expression sets.
1. press item for IAWA journal (Rachel, Frederic, Barb, Andrew)
Frederic will write draft of announcement and send it to group for review.
2. Contact groups developing high throughput and genome data (Jill)
-for advertizing and getting them to send us data
3. Write a research paper (Whole group)
Need to make sure that ontologies are in pretty good shape first so when we send people to it, they will find it useful.
RW and LC are willing to take the lead on writing.
Use case: make sure PO and Hardwood Genomics.org are linking effectively to each other (Meg)
Data and analysis (LC, Andrew and/or Jill?)
Submit by fall 2012.
4. Ontology workshop at IAWA meeting -- in Japan in 2013
5. Participation in Forest Tree workshop at PAG next year. All day Sunday. (Lol and Jill. Jill can talk to coordinators)
Can be very competitive to get in it. Alternative is to have our own workshop and have the forest tree workshop group advertise it to their list
- Contact PAG forest tree workshop organizers about possible talk at their workshop- Sunday of PAG
IAWA Multilingual Glossary of Terms Used in Wood Anatomy
Link to references from EW on Inside Wood
Metcalfe and Chalk "Anatomy of the Dicotyledons" 1st edition 1950 + the more recent recent volumes
Carlquist's Comparative Plant Anatomy
Larson's "The Vascular Cambium"
Pickard, W. F. 2008. Laticifers and secretory ducts: two other tube systems in plants. New Phytologist 177: 877-888(12)
Sanchez, P., Nehlin, L., and Greb, T. (2012). From thin to thick: major transitions during stem development. Trends in Plant Science 17, 113–121.